acthub.beta
EnactedRoyal Assentc. 29

Civil Liability Act 2018

This bill became lawView the statute on acthub →c. 29 · 20 Dec 2018

Bill texts 5

  • HL Bill 90 (as introduced)Bill · 20 Mar 2018download soon
  • HL Bill 110 (as amended on Report)Bill · 12 Jun 2018download soon
  • Bill 240 2017-19, as introducedBill · 28 Jun 2018download soon
  • Bill 264 2017-19 (as amended in Committee)Bill · 12 Sept 2018download soon
  • HL Bill 135 Commons amendmentsBill · 24 Oct 2018download soon

Amendments 46

Committee stage — Lords 20

WithdrawnClause 1EditBillBody

leave out subsection (1) and insert— In this Part, “whiplash injury” means an injury or set of injuries resulting in soft tissue damage, usually of the neck, back or shoulder, arising out of a motor accident, which presents symptoms which may include pain and aches (including pain of the jaw, neck, back, and shooting pains in the neck, shoulder or arms), headaches, stiffness, fatigue, dizziness, swelling, bruising, tenderness or muscle spasms.”

Moved: The Earl of Kinnoull#9544
NotMovedClause 1EditBillBody

leave out subsections (1) and (2) and insert— Subject to regulations made by the Lord Chancellor under subsection (2), in this Part “whiplash injury” means a soft tissue injury which—

Moved: Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts#9576
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “psychological”

Moved: The Earl of KinnoullSponsor: Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts#9577
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “psychological”

Moved: The Earl of KinnoullSponsor: Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts#9578
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “psychological”

Moved: The Earl of KinnoullSponsor: Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts#9580
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “psychological”

Moved: The Earl of KinnoullSponsor: Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts#9581
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “psychological”

Moved: The Earl of KinnoullSponsor: Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts#9582
WithdrawnClause 1EditBillBody

leave out “, back or shoulder”

Moved: Lord BeechamSponsor: Lord McKenzie of Luton#9620
NotMovedClause 1EditBillBody

after “specified” insert “by the Chief Medical Officer of the Department of Health and set out”

Moved: Lord BeechamSponsor: Lord McKenzie of Luton#9621
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “two years” and insert “twelve months”

Moved: Lord BeechamSponsor: Lord McKenzie of Luton, Baroness Berridge#9623
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “two years” and insert “twelve months”

Moved: Lord BeechamSponsor: Lord McKenzie of Luton, Baroness Berridge#9624
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out sub-paragraph (ii)

Moved: Lord BeechamSponsor: Lord McKenzie of Luton#9625
NotMovedClause 1EditBillBody

leave out from “injuries,” to end of line 14 and insert “that affect the vertebrae or soft tissue in the neck, back or shoulder and any consequential psychological injury.”

Moved: Lord SharkeySponsor: Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames, Baroness Berridge#9627
NotMovedClause 1EditBillBody

leave out subsection (5)

Moved: Lord SharkeySponsor: Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames#9629
WithdrawnClause 2EditBillBody

leave out from “amount” to end of line 13 on page 3 and insert “determined in accordance with the 14th edition of the Judicial College Guidelines for the Assessment of General Damages in Personal Injury Cases or any subsequent revision to these guidelines.”

Moved: Lord SharkeySponsor: Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames#9631
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out from “in” to end of line 18 on page 3 and insert “the table of tariffs set out in Schedule 1. The Lord Chancellor may by regulations made by statutory instrument amend Schedule 1.

Moved: Lord SharkeySponsor: Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames#9648
WithdrawnClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “specified” and insert “recommended annually by the Civil Justice Council and set out”

Moved: Lord BeechamSponsor: Lord McKenzie of Luton, Baroness Berridge#9649
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

at end insert— Before making regulations under subsection (2), the Lord Chancellor must consult the Lord Chief Justice and obtain the agreement of the Judicial College to the amount to be specified in the regulations.”

Moved: Lord Bassam of Brighton#9651
WithdrawnClause 1EditBillBody

at end insert— Regulations may be informed by a review from time to time of relevant changes in motor vehicle technology and driving techniques.”

Moved: Lord McKenzie of Luton#9675
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

at end insert— Before making regulations under this section, the Lord Chancellor must consult the judiciary and the Judicial College Guidelines.”

Moved: Baroness Berridge#9678

Report stage — Lords 20

AgreedClause 1EditBillBody

leave out from “an” to end of line 7 and insert “injury of soft tissue in the neck, back or shoulder that is of a description falling within subsection (1A), but not including an injury excepted by subsection (1B). An injury falls within this subsection if it is—

Moved: Lord Keen of ElieSponsor: The Earl of Kinnoull#9789
AgreedClause 1EditBillBody

leave out subsection (2)

Moved: Lord Keen of ElieSponsor: The Earl of Kinnoull#9790
AgreedClause 1EditBillBody

leave out subsection (5)

Moved: Lord Keen of ElieSponsor: The Earl of Kinnoull#9791
AgreedClause 1AddClauseOrSchedule

Insert the following new Clause— “Power to amend section 1

Moved: Lord Keen of Elie#9792
AgreedClause 2EditBillBody

after “injury” insert “or any of the whiplash injuries suffered on that occasion”

Moved: Lord Keen of Elie#9793
AgreedClause 2EditBillBody

after “injury” insert “or injuries, taken together,”

Moved: Lord Keen of Elie#9794
AgreedClause 2EditBillBody

after “injury” insert “or injuries”

Moved: Lord Keen of Elie#9795
AgreedClause 2EditBillBody

after “injury” insert “or injuries”

Moved: Lord Keen of Elie#9796
AgreedClause 2EditBillBody

after “injury” insert “or injuries”

Moved: Lord Keen of Elie#9797
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

at end insert— In this section “duration of the whiplash injury” means the duration of the whiplash injury which a person has suffered, or is likely to suffer, assuming they take or have taken reasonable steps to mitigate that injury.”

Moved: Lord SharkeySponsor: Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames#9820
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out subsection (2) and insert— The total amount of damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenity payable in respect of a whiplash injury or in respect of both a whiplash injury and one or more minor psychological injuries suffered on the same occasion as the whiplash injury (“the tariff amount” for the purposes of section 3(7)) is—

Moved: Lord SharkeySponsor: Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames#9831
DisagreedClause 2DeleteClauseOrSchedule

Leave out Clause 2

Moved: Lord WoolfSponsor: Lord Beecham, Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames#9853
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

at end insert— The Lord Chancellor must consult the Lord Chief Justice before making regulations under this section.”

Moved: Lord JudgeSponsor: Lord Hope of Craighead, Lord Mackay of Clashfern, Lord Pannick#9856
WithdrawnClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “two years” and insert “twelve months”

Moved: Baroness ChakrabartiSponsor: Lord Beecham, Lord Woolf#9866
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out “two years” and insert “twelve months”

Moved: Baroness ChakrabartiSponsor: Lord Beecham#9867
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out sub-paragraph (ii)

Moved: Lord BeechamSponsor: Baroness Chakrabarti#9868
NotMovedClause 1EditBillBody

after “specified” insert “by the Chief Medical Officer of the Department of Health and set out”

Moved: Baroness ChakrabartiSponsor: Lord Beecham#9910
NotMovedClause 2EditBillBody

leave out from “amount” to end of line 13 on page 3 and insert “determined in accordance with the 14th edition of the Judicial College Guidelines for the Assessment of General Damages in Personal Injury Cases or any subsequent revision to these guidelines.”

Moved: Lord BeechamSponsor: Baroness Chakrabarti#9911
WithdrawnClause 1EditBillBody

leave out second “the person” and insert “that person”

Moved: Lord BerkeleySponsor: Lord Young of Norwood Green#9914
NotMovedClause 2AddClauseOrSchedule

Leave out Clause 2 and insert the following new Clause— “Damages for whiplash injuries

Moved: Lord WoolfSponsor: Lord Beecham, Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames#9915

3rd reading — Lords 6

WithdrawnClause 10EditBillBody

leave out lines 3 to 5

Moved: Lord Hope of Craighead#9927
AgreedClause 10EditBillBody

leave out “3” and insert “5”

Moved: Lord FaulksSponsor: The Earl of Kinnoull#9929
AgreedClause 10EditBillBody

leave out “3” and insert “5”

Moved: Lord FaulksSponsor: The Earl of Kinnoull#9930
AgreedClause 10EditBillBody

leave out “three” and insert “five”

Moved: Lord FaulksSponsor: The Earl of Kinnoull#9931
AgreedClause 10EditBillBody

leave out “3” and insert “5”

Moved: Lord FaulksSponsor: The Earl of Kinnoull#9950
AgreedClause 13EditBillBody

leave out “This Part comes” and insert “Part 2 and this Part come”

Moved: Lord SharkeySponsor: The Earl of Kinnoull#9953