acthub.beta

EnactedScotland Act 2016

Read the text →
OverviewTimeline106Debates18Amendments117

Proposed amendments

117 amendments across 27 provisions

Clause 1 9

Amendment 6#196No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out lines 15 to 17 and insert—
Subsection (1) may only be repealed if—

The Bills API publishes only the tabling instruction here, not the inserted text itself — the full wording is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
1
Page
1
Line
15
Marshalled no.
6
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 1
Amendment 7#80No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out “Scotland voting in a referendum” and insert, “a two-thirds majority in a vote of the House of Commons in which 75 per cent of the members elected by Scottish constituencies voted for abolition"
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
1
Page
1
Line
17
Marshalled no.
7
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 1

Clause 2 13

Amendment 12#197No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out lines 5 to 7 and insert—
“(8) But the Parliament of the United Kingdom may not pass Acts applying to Scotland that make provision about a devolved matter without the consent of the Scottish Parliament.
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
2
Page
2
Line
5
Marshalled no.
12
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 2
Amendment 16#188No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
after “matters” insert “, and
to alter the legislative competence of the Scottish Parliament or the executive competence of the Scottish Government”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
2
Page
2
Line
6
Marshalled no.
16
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 2
Amendment 19#226No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert "but the decision as to whether or not the circumstances are such as to allow the Parliament of the United Kingdom to legislate with regard to any devolved matter be a decision for that Parliament to take, and shall not be justiciable in any court of law."
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
2
Page
2
Line
7
Marshalled no.
19
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 2
Amendment 20#198No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert—
“(2) After section 28 of the Scotland Act 1998 insert—

The Bills API publishes only the tabling instruction here, not the inserted text itself — the full wording is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
2
Page
2
Line
5
Marshalled no.
20
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 2
Amendment 21#199No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Scottish Senate

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
2
Marshalled no.
21
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 2
Amendment 22#227No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
"Cooperation between the Scottish and United Kingdom institutions

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
2
Marshalled no.
22
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 2

Clause 3 1

Clause 4 2

Clause 5 1

Amendment 26#73No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Interval between elections

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
5
Marshalled no.
26
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 5

Clause 8 1

Clause 10 1

Amendment 28#97No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Provision under sections 3 to 10

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
10
Marshalled no.
28
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 10

Clause 11 12

Amendment 29#228No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out from “heading” to end of line 6 and insert “, omit “before introduction"."
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
11
Page
12
Line
6
Marshalled no.
29
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 11
Amendment 31#216No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert—
“( ) the period between general elections specified in section 2(2),”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
11
Page
12
Line
19
Marshalled no.
31
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 11
Amendment 36#74No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out from “unless” to end of line 31 and insert “, having been approved at the final stage by the Scottish Parliament, it is then approved by a resolution of each House of the United Kingdom Parliament”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
11
Page
12
Line
29
Marshalled no.
36
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 11
Amendment 38#221No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert—
Subsection (5) applies where—

The Bills API publishes only the tabling instruction here, not the inserted text itself — the full wording is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
11
Page
13
Line
22
Marshalled no.
38
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 11
Amendment 39#222No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
In subsection (4) after paragraph (a) insert—
Where section 32A(2)(b) applies—

The Bills API publishes only the tabling instruction here, not the inserted text itself — the full wording is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
11
Page
13
Line
32
Marshalled no.
39
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 11
Amendment 40#223No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert—
After subsection (4) insert—

The Bills API publishes only the tabling instruction here, not the inserted text itself — the full wording is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
11
Page
13
Line
32
Marshalled no.
40
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 11

Clause 12 2

Amendment 41#200No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert—
In paragraph 1(2)(f) of Schedule 4 (protection of Scotland Act 1998 from modification), after “Human Rights Act 1998” insert “except the Convention rights set out in Schedule 1 to that Act”.”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
12
Page
14
Line
6
Marshalled no.
41
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 12
Amendment 42#106No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Convention

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
12
Marshalled no.
42
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 12

Clause 19 3

Amendment 75#109No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Non-devolved taxes and the Scottish Consolidated Fund: further provisions

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
19
Marshalled no.
75
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 19
Amendment 75A#314No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
"Borrowing powers

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
19
Marshalled no.
75A
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 19
Amendment 76#201No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Fiscal framework: review

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
19
Marshalled no.
76
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 19

Clause 20 1

Amendment 77#113No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out lines 4 to 12 and insert—
“a disabled person or person with a physical or mental impairment or health condition in respect of effects or needs arising from that disability, impairment or health condition.”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
20
Page
23
Line
4
Marshalled no.
77
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 20

Clause 28 1

Amendment 78#118No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Joint Committee on Welfare Devolution

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
28
Marshalled no.
78
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 28

Clause 29 1

Clause 34 9

Amendment 44#202No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out “may” and insert “must following agreement with the Scottish Government”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
34
Page
33
Line
18
Marshalled no.
44
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 34
Amendment 45#229No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out from second “the” to “(“the transferee”)” and insert “Scottish Crown Estate Commissioners”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
34
Page
33
Line
20
Marshalled no.
45
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 34
Amendment 47#230No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert —
The Secretary of State shall, by regulations made by statutory instrument, specify the powers and functions of the Scottish Crown Estate Commissioners.
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
34
Page
33
Line
21
Marshalled no.
47
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 34
Amendment 48#189No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert—
“(2A) The Treasury and Scottish Ministers must agree a scheme transferring to the control of each of Shetland Islands Council, Orkney Islands Council and Comhairle nan Eilean Siar (“the island authorities”) on the transfer date all the existing Scottish functions and rights of the Commissioners relating to those parts of the Scottish zone surrounding each of the island authorities.
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
34
Page
33
Line
27
Marshalled no.
48
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 34

Clause 35 13

Amendment 52A#247No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
and insert—
““The subject matter of sections 104 to 106 of the Equality Act 2010 (special provision for political parties) in relation to elections to the Scottish Parliament and local government elections in Scotland. The provision within this section does not include any modification of section 104(6) or (7).
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
35
Page
37
Line
6
Marshalled no.
52A
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 35
Amendment 52E#251No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert—
In section 105(2) (time-limited provision) after the words “Minister of the Crown” insert “or, in relation to elections to the Scottish Parliament and local government elections in Scotland, Scottish Ministers,”.
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
35
Page
37
Line
45
Marshalled no.
52E
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 35
Amendment 52AD#550No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out “the Acts do” and insert “that Act does ”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
35
Page
37
Line
20
Marshalled no.
52AD
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 35
Amendment 52CA#553No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
leave out from first “Act” to “are” in line 33 and insert “2010 and any subordinate legislation made under that Act”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
35
Page
37
Line
32
Marshalled no.
52CA
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 35

Clause 37 3

Clause 41 1

Amendment 53#160No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Obstructive parking

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
41
Marshalled no.
53
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 41

Clause 42 1

Amendment 53A#646No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
after “property” insert “; but this exception does not apply in relation to the abolition or dissolution of the British Transport Police”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
42
Page
45
Line
44
Marshalled no.
53A
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 42

Clause 43 1

Amendment Unnumbered#75No decisionRemoves provision
Amendment text
Lord Forsyth of Drumlean gives notice of his intention to oppose the Question that Clause 43 stand part of the Bill.
Stage
Committee stage
Type
DeleteClauseOrSchedule
Clause
43
Marshalled no.
Unnumbered
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 43

Clause 49 5

Amendment 55#128No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert “and the designation of licensing standards officers in Scotland as authorised persons for the exercise of inspection and enforcement functions in respect of such licences”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
49
Page
51
Line
37
Marshalled no.
55
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 49
Amendment 57#161No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert—
“( ) In section 304 of that Act (authorised persons), after subsection (4)(c) insert—

The Bills API publishes only the tabling instruction here, not the inserted text itself — the full wording is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
49
Page
52
Line
7
Marshalled no.
57
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 49

Clause 50 5

Amendment 59#206No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Business Associations

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
50
Marshalled no.
59
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 50
Amendment 60#207No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Regulation of solicitors

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
50
Marshalled no.
60
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 50
Amendment 61#231No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
"Estate agency

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
50
Marshalled no.
61
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 50
Amendment 62#232No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
"Health and Safety

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
50
Marshalled no.
62
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 50
Amendment 62A#333No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Industrial relations

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
50
Marshalled no.
62A
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 50

Clause 54 2

Clause 58 11

Amendment 73#137No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Ofgem’s Energy Strategy and Policy Statement

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
58
Marshalled no.
73
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 58

Clause 64 3

Amendment 73A#330No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
"Economy of areas adjoining Scotland: report

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
64
Marshalled no.
73A
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 64
Amendment 73B#331No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
"Political and economic impact of this Act on the United Kingdom

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
64
Marshalled no.
73B
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 64
Amendment 73C#647No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“Economy of areas adjoining Scotland: report

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
64
Marshalled no.
73C
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 64

Clause 68 7

Amendment Unnumbered#705No decisionRemoves provision
Amendment text
Lord Forsyth of Drumlean gives notice of his intention to oppose the Question that Clause 68 stand part of the Bill.
Stage
Committee stage
Type
DeleteClauseOrSchedule
Clause
68
Marshalled no.
Unnumbered
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 68
Amendment 79F#706No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Clause—
“The fiscal framework

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Clause
68
Marshalled no.
79F
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 68

Clause 69 7

Amendment 80#235No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
Page 75, line 17, leave out subsections (1) to (6) and insert—
“(1) Sections 13 to 68 of this Act shall not come into force until such time as the relevant Secretary of State has laid before Parliament a statement to the effect that the Secretary of State is satisfied that the Scottish Government and any Scottish authorities to which power is devolved under this Act have the appropriate arrangements in place with which to exercise the relevant power devolved under this Act.
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
69
Page
75
Line
17
Marshalled no.
80
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 69
Amendment 81#236No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert
Section 34 shall not come into force until such time as the Secretary of State has laid a report before Parliament which sets out which persons will initially be nominated by Scottish Ministers under subsection 90B(1) in Part5 of the Scotland Act 1998 as Scottish Crown Estate Commissioners, what arrangements will be put in place to facilitate the transfer of functions touch persons and what arrangements the Scottish Ministers have made for the further devolution of the management of Crown Estate assets.”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
69
Page
75
Line
20
Marshalled no.
81
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 69
Amendment 83#237No decisionAmends text
Amendment text
at end insert–
Any section or subsection of this Act which grants a power to Scottish Ministers or to other authorities in Scotland is repealed at the end of the period of three years beginning on the day on which this Act is passed if the power granted under that section or subsection has not yet been exercised.”
Stage
Committee stage
Type
EditBillBody
Clause
69
Page
75
Line
38
Marshalled no.
83
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Clause 69

Schedule 1 1

Amendment 74#139No decisionNew clause / schedule
Amendment text
Insert the following new Schedule—
“SCHEDULE

Only the heading is published via the Bills API — the full text of this new clause/schedule is set out in the marshalled Amendment Paper.

Stage
Committee stage
Type
AddClauseOrSchedule
Position
After
Schedule
1
Marshalled no.
74
Decision
The House has not considered this amendment.
Tabled againstAs brought from the Commons· Schedule 1